The Orphic Moment

2014 / For countertenor, violin & orchestra

The story of Orpheus is music’s founding myth, its primal self-justification and self-glorification. On Orpheus’s wedding day, his wife Eurydice is fatally bitten by a poisonous snake. Orpheus audaciously storms the gates of hell to plead his case, in song, to Hades and his infernal gang. The guardians of death melt at his music’s touch. They grant Eurydice a second chance at life: she may follow Orpheus back to earth, on the one condition that he not turn to look at her until they’re above ground. Orpheus can’t resist his urge to glance back; he turns, and Eurydice vanishes.

The Orpheus myth is typically understood as a tragedy of human impatience: even when a loved one’s life is at stake, the best, most heroic intentions are helpless to resist a sudden instinctive impulse. But that’s not my understanding of the story. Orpheus, after all, is the ultimate aesthete: he’s the world’s greatest singer, and he knows that heartbreak and loss are music’s favorite subjects. In most operas based on the Orpheus story – and there are many – the action typically runs as follows: Orpheus loses Eurydice; he laments her loss gorgeously and extravagantly; he descends to the underworld; he gorgeously and extravagantly begs to get Eurydice back; he is granted her again and promptly loses her again; he laments even more gorgeously and extravagantly than before.


"The Orpheus myth is typically understood as a tragedy of human impatience: even when a loved one’s life is at stake, the best, most heroic intentions are helpless to resist a sudden instinctive impulse. But that’s not my understanding of the story."

So might this backwards glance be a conscious gesture? Might Eurydice’s second death be not an accident but a kind of murder? Or, if Orpheus does look back out of a sudden impulse, might that impulse be the aesthetic one, the seductive and amoral tendency to value art above one’s fellow human beings? I take this interpretation to an extreme in The Orphic Moment, a “dramatic cantata” that shines a magnifying glass on the final moments before Orpheus turns around. Up to the moment when the piece begins, Orpheus’s conscious intentions have been noble: he has risked his life to rescue Eurydice, he’s succeeded, and they are walking toward the light. But as the piece begins, he has a second thought: “It has been life to lose you,” he says. “It has been life to go without…”. He muses on what would happen if he lost Eurydice again. A second death…the loss of Eurydice at the very moment when she was about to be granted life…nothing could be more tragic than that. It’s bound to inspire the greatest music ever.

The solo violin is Eurydice, wordlessly calling to Orpheus, growing more and more unsettled as she senses his emotional withdrawal. In the second half of the piece, Orpheus calculates the perfect moment to aim his gaze backwards at Eurydice. Patiently, coldly, he waits until light from the world above begins to filter down through the soil. He slowly turns his head. The scene goes dark.

Rent or purchase The Orphic Moment

Read the review at The New York Times
Read the review at Broadway World
Read the Opera News feature


Listen to an excerpt of The Orphic Moment, featuring countertenor Anthony Roth Costanzo, violinist Keir GoGwilt, and members of A Far Cry conducted by Matthew Aucoin
The Orphic Moment at National Sawdust

The Orphic Moment at Music Academy of the West


For countertenor, violin & orchestra
Category:Soloist(s) and Large Ensemble
Year Composed:2014
Duration:15 Minutes
Soloist:Countertenor [=Mezzo-Soprano], Violin
Text Writer:the composer
Publisher:Associated Music Publishers Inc
Past Performances

06 & 07 JUN 2014
The Orphic Moment – World Premiere
Peabody Essex Museum
Salem MA
Encounters Ensemble
Anthony Roth Costanzo, countertenor; Keir GoGwilt, violin; Matthew Aucoin, conductor
23 JUN 2015
The Orphic Moment
Rockport Chamber Music Festival
Rockport, MA
23 & 24 MAR 2016
The Orphic Moment – New York Premiere
National Sawdust
Brooklyn, NY
Manhattan School of Music Orchestra
Anthony Roth Costanzo, countertenor; Keir GoGwilt, solo violin; Matthew Aucoin, conductor
18 & 19 NOV 2016
The Orphic Moment
The Colburn School
Los Angeles, CA
LA Opera Young Artists
22, 24, & 26 JAN; 8 & 10 FEB 2017
The Orphic Moment – Austria Premiere
Salzburger Landestheater
Salzburg, Austria
Anthony Roth Costanza, countertenor
24 MAY 2017
The Orphic Moment – Country Premiere
Toronto, ON, Canada
Canadian Opera Company Orchestra
Johannes Debus, conductor
06 JUL 2017
The Orphic Moment
Hahn Hall
Santa Barbara, CA
Music Academy of the West
23 FEB 2018
The Orphic Moment
Metamorphoses: Orpheus in Oedipus
Cambridge, MA
Emmanuel Music
06 & 07 MAY 2018
The Orphic Moment
Rose Theater, Jazz at Lincoln Center
New York, NY
Ted Sperling, conductor
04 MAR 2019
The Orphic Moment
First Congregational Church
Sarasota, FL
Thea Lobo, mezzo-soprano; Samantha Bennett, violin; Matthew Aucoin, conductor
Reviewable Score